Best Self Storage Units in Indianapolis, IN

In order to pick the top 14 storage units companies in Indianapolis, we looked at all 133 facilities in the area, including an in-depth review of each company’s amenities, features, and customer reviews.

Our Selection Criteria

Our goal is to connect people with the best local storage facilities. We analyzed every single storage facility in the area and rated them based on 30 different variables to pick the best storage unit facilities in Indianapolis.

  • shape-1 133
    Facilities Reviewed
  • shape-1 76
    Facilities Curated
  • shape-1 14
    Top Picks
  • 1. Reputation

    A history of great customer reviews and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

The 14 Best Storage Facilities in Indianapolis

Show Map

Affordable Family Storage

10901 E Washington Indianapolis, IN 46229

Affordable Family Storage is located in East Washington just a few minutes away from US Highway 40. All units are indoor and have individual locks for added security. Video surveillance is also in place to protect units and tenants and access is offered from 6 am to 10 pm daily. Reservations can be made online or in-person and monthly payments can be made online for added convenience. Packing supplies are available for purchase in the office during normal office hours and hand carts are available to borrow for move-in. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

A first-time storage customer wrote that she was “very impressed with the cleanliness and current promotion” and had a great first impression. Another person noted it was “closely guarded” with “reasonable prices.”

Arlington Self Storage

3231 North Arlington Avenue Indianapolis, IN 46218

Locally owned and operated, Arlington Self-Storage offers both standard and climate-controlled outdoor units with individual door alarms for extra security. All units offer drive-up access and large aisleways can accommodate moving trucks. Customers are able to access the fully fenced facility from 5 am to 10 pm daily via an electronic gate and LED lighting helps illuminate units after dark. The facility is protected by digital surveillance and also offers indoor RV and boat storage solutions along with outdoor parking spots. In addition, second-floor office space is available for lease and comes with complimentary housekeeping. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers are happy at Arlington Self Storage with one customer noting “the space is perfect for our needs” and adding the office manager is “friendly and professional.” Another happy customer stated it is “well maintained and clean.”

Beech Grove Storage

4850 Emerson Avenue Indianapolis, IN 46203

Situated easily off I-465, Beech Grove Storage offers customers standard storage units to customers with roll-up doors and ground floor access. Customers can access their storage units 24/7 and extra protection is provided by an electronic gate that requires personalized digital codes for entry. In addition, the facility is protected by continual video surveillance and a resident manager lives on the site. The fully fenced facility offers customers month to month leases and the option to pay online. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Several people noted that Beech Grove Storage offers a “good price on storage units” and also that the facility is kept “very clean.” Another reviewer said the storage facility offered “exactly what I wanted when I needed it.”

Brookville Road Self Storage

1251 Interchange Way Indianapolis, IN 46239

Brookville Road Self-Storage is a large storage facility that offers climate-controlled and standard units to residential and commercial clients. A 24-hour rental kiosk makes contactless service possible and the family-owned storage facility accepts monthly payments online. Most units offer drive-up access and large aisleways allow for moving trucks to easily fit through. The fully fenced facility features motion detection video cameras and an electronic gate that controls entry. Gate hours are 6 am to 10 pm every day and 24/7 access can be arranged. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Many people rave about the great customer service at Brookville Road Self-Storage calling them “professional and “helpful and quick to provide excellent customer service.” Another Reviewer enjoyed that it is “super clean and centrally located for easy access.”

Foxes Den Self Storage

633 N. Lynhurst Drive Indianapolis, IN 46224

Located just a few minutes from downtown in the Speedway area, Foxes Den Self-Storage offers residential and commercial clients standard storage solutions. All units offer drive-up access with wide aisleways and the entire facility is fenced and well-lit for security purposes. Access is permitted 24/7 via an individualized access code at the electronic gate and reservations can be made online. Payments can also be made online, or auto-pay can be set up. RV, boat, and car storage can be arranged, and all leases are assigned on a month by month basis. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Reviewers enjoy the 24-hour access at Foxes Den Self-Storage and call the rates “very affordable.” Another reviewer stated that it offers “friendly staff” and “good prices.” An annual user of the facility called them “very trustworthy.”

Geist Self Storage

11575 Fox Road Indianapolis, IN 46236

Geist Self-Storage offers customers an array of self-storage options that include climate-controlled and standard units. Many of the standard units offer drive-up access for easy move-in. The storage facility also offers customers the use of a free truck at move-in, but reservations must be made in advance and drivers must have valid licenses and insurance. A resident manager is available during regular office hours and moving supplies can be purchased in the office. Tenants are also invited to take advantage of free coffee in the office and document shredding service. Tenants have access to their units 24/7 and have the option to make online payments. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

People enjoy the hassle-free nature of self-storage at Geist Self-Storage explaining it as “the easiest process I have ever undergone.” Several people mentioned the great office staff calling them “exceptional,” “helpful,” and “patient and kind.”

Hoosier Storage

17749 Sun Park Drive Westfield, IN 46074

Locally owned and operated, Hoosier Storage is located near the Westfield Post Office close to the US-31 and State Rd. 32 intersection. The storage facility offers standard storage units with drive-up access on the ground floor. Access hours are 24/7 for the convenience of the client, and the lot is protected by an electronic digital gate. In addition, the fenced facility has video surveillance in place. Leases are available on a monthly basis and payments are accepted online. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

A short time tenant of Hoosier Storage wrote that the manager was “easy to work with, and I was very pleased with the overall experience.” Another reviewer echoed these thoughts writing that it is “very convenient” and that the “24/7 access is great.”

Infinite Self Storage

8802 Evergreen Avenue Indianapolis, IN 46240

Infinite Self-Storage makes obtaining a storage unit easy by allowing 24/7 access and offering a 24-hour rental kiosk where customers can easily reserve a unit and gain access without making any contact with the office. Despite the around the clock access, the facility is kept safe via a coded gate that can only be opened with a unique code and surveillance cameras. All units also feature their own high cylinder lock which must be purchased by the tenant. Deposits are not required, and all units are rented on a monthly basis. Moving supplies are available for purchase in the office and online payment is available. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

A tenant of several years stated the manager always offers “great service” and likes the fact the “property is cleaned and well maintained.” Another reviewer called the staff “nice and informative” and the units “nice and spacious" as well as "well-lit."

Infinite Self Storage

1102 East 52nd Street Indianapolis, IN 46205

Infinite Self Storage of Broad Ripple offers standard storage solutions to residential and commercial clients as well as 24/7 accessibility so that storage is convenient to you. The office makes moving easy by offering moving boxes and packing supplies for sale during normal hours. Both interior rooms and drive-up units are available based on the size of the storage unit you need, and individual keys are assigned to each unit. The fenced facility is protected by an electronic coded entry gate and video surveillance is in place. All units are rented on a monthly basis and online payment options are available. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Reviewers speak highly of Infinite Self-Storage with several people mentioning the manager who they described as “extremely helpful” and “very friendly.” One tenant mentioned that it offers “great location and flexible terms.”

Keystone Self Storage

5030 North Keystone Avenue Indianapolis, IN 46205

Located in a busy metro area of Indy, Keystone Self Storage offers a wide array of climate-controlled storage units ranging from 5’ x 5’ to 10’ x 30’ for commercial and residential tenants. Most units offer pull-up access and the entire lot is protected by 24-hour surveillance. Tenants are allowed to access their units 24/7 and moving supplies can be purchased in the office during normal hours. Reservations and monthly payments can be made online to ensure contactless service. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

People leave positive reviews of Keystone Self Storage with one reviewer noting it is “secure” with “super friendly staff.” Another called the staff “fantastic” explaining they are “polite, intelligent about storage, and very funny.”

Mt. Comfort Storage LLC

6263 West Stoner Drive Greenfield, IN 46140

Situated near the Indianapolis Regional Airport on the eastside of Indianapolis, Mt. Comfort Self Storage offers climate-controlled and standard storage units for commercial and residential clients. Many units on the ground floor offer drive-up access for easy move-in. Wide aisleways can accommodate trucks and the paved lot makes moving with carts or dollies simple. Dollies are available in the office during normal hours along with packing supplies. The gated lot offers 24/7 access to customers who are protected by around the clock video surveillance. RV, boat, and car parking is also available, and tenants have access to a free moving truck when they move-in. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

People rave about Mt. Comfort Storage noting the “friendly” staff and enjoying the “use of their moving truck for free.” Another customer described the facility as “clean” and “secure” and the manager as “always friendly and accommodating.”

Never Enough Self Storage

10309 E. 56th Street Indianapolis, IN 46236

Conveniently located right off Pendleton Pike on the east side of Indy, Never Enough Storage offers simple storage solutions to customers. Outdoor units with drive-up access range in size from 5’ x 10’ to 20’ x 30’ and utilize keyed cylinder locks for excellent protection. The fenced facility allows access 24/7 via an electronic digital gate and 24-hour video surveillance is in place. There are never any paperwork fees and no deposits are required. Leases are available on a monthly basis and payments are accepted online. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers are happy at Never Enough Storage with one client called it “secure storage” with “friendly managers.” Another reviewer commented it was “very convenient” with “polite and great service.”

Southern Dunes Self Storage

7425 Wellingshire Boulevard Indianapolis, IN 46217

Located right off Route 37 in close proximity to the Southern Dunes Golf Course, Southern Dunes Self-Storage offers customers an array of climate-controlled storage units. The fully fenced facility prides itself on making storage easy with a simple reservation process and helpful staff. Cylinder locks protect all units and 24-hour security surveillance is in place to secure units. Access hours are from 5 am to 10 pm daily and are controlled by an electronic digital gate. Pest control services are preventatively booked three times a year and there is a manager on-site daily. RV & boat covered storage is also available along with tenant insurance. Discounts are available for military and civil servants. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Most tenants are happy with the service at Southern Dunes Self Storage calling staff “attentive” and “kind, patient, understanding, and beyond professional.” Another reviewer mentioned the “facility and grounds are very clean and well kept.”

Store It Indy

4530 N Keystone Avenue Indianapolis, IN 46205

Store Indy offers an array of climate-controlled and climate-controlled and heated units in many different sizes all of which are indoors. The facility offers five levels of security including surveillance cameras and utilizes electronic controlled access to limit who is inside the grounds at all times. There is a loading dock as well as ground-level drive-up areas and loading carts are available in the office. Automatic payment plans are available, or tenants can sign a month-to-month lease free of any deposits or administration fees. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Tenants are happy with Stor It Indy with many noting the price is “cheap” but it's “always clean” and the office manager is “friendly and helpful.” Another tenant described the units as “well lit” as well as “dry and clean” adding that she would “definitely recommend them.”

The Cost of Self Storage in Indianapolis, IN

The average costs of storage units in Indianapolis are below the state and national averages for the most common storage unit sizes. Storage unit costs will vary depending on the various amenities the facility offers, so shop around to make sure you’re only paying for what you need.

The average cost of storage units in Indianapolis compared to state and national averages
Size of Storage Unit City Average State Average National Average
5×5 $30 $35 $41
5×10 $47 $52 $59
10×10 $74 $76 $95
10×15 $92 $94 $114
10×20 $102 $108 $133