Best Self Storage Units in Anderson, Indianapolis of 2022

In order to pick the top 19 storage units companies in Anderson, we looked at all 181 facilities in the area, including an in-depth review of each company’s amenities, features, and customer reviews.

Our Selection Criteria

Our goal is to connect people with the best local storage facilities. We analyzed every single storage facility in the area and rated them based on 30 different variables to pick the best storage unit facilities in Anderson.

  • shape-1 181
    Facilities Reviewed
  • shape-1 103
    Facilities Curated
  • shape-1 19
    Top Picks
  • 1. Customer Service

    A record of outstanding customer reviews and service.

  • 2. Amenities

    Offers the most important features popular with customers.

  • 3. Location

    Multiple nearby facilities for maximum convenience.

  • 4. Professionalism

    A reputation of honest and reliable business practices.

The 19 Best Storage Facilities in Anderson

Hide Map

Affordable Family Storage

Multiple Locations

Affordable Family Storage features a friendly and professional staff that helps customers find a storage solution that suits their needs. Its temperature-controlled units protect weather-sensitive items for the short and long term. Renters' items are secure at all times because the building is equipped with a computerized gate entry. The drive-up units allow customers to pull up directly. Security features include video cameras and secured access doors. Also, this company sells boxes and moving supplies. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

“The process of securing a unit was pretty straightforward. I like when processes like these are straightforward. I definitely recommend it.”

Amazon Self Storage

8299 South SR 13 Pendleton, IN 46064

At Amazon Self Storage, customers can find the right space to accommodate their belongings because units are available in sizes ranging from 5x10 to 10x30. There are climate-controlled units that are perfect for clients with temperature-sensitive items. This property has digital cameras and gate keypads to secure renters’ items. Additional security measures include an on-site management office. The company accepts credit card auto-pay and allows for packages for businesses. Clients also enjoy the month-to-month leases. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

“The manager has always been very nice and helpful. Property has always been kept clean and plowed when it snows. I highly recommend this facility.”

Ameri-Stor Storage in McCordsville

8023 N 600 W Mccordsville, IN 46055

Ameri-Stor Storage is a new self-storage facility that opened its doors in 2008 to meet its clientele's personal and business needs. It has climate-controlled and traditional units ranging from 5x5 to 12x35, accommodating various office and household items. This location has spacious outside parking where tenants can park their trailers, RVs, boats, and cars. For extra security, the building is fenced and gated with keypads and has video cameras. Packing supplies are also available on-site. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

“Good location, friendly employees.”

Anderson Storage Solutions

5648 SR-9 N Anderson, IN 46012

Homeowners and businesses can find Anderson Storage Solutions right off State Road 9 in Anderson. It offers a variety of unit sizes ranging from 5x6 to 10x12. The facility’s online software lets customers book and make payments online and manage their units from the convenience of their home. Tenants have 24-hour access to their belongings. Other amenities at this location include drive-up access and digital video surveillance. Parking space is also available. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

“Great pricing, always quick to respond.”

Cardinal Self Storage

5327 Doctor M.L.K. Jr Boulevard Anderson, IN 46013

Family-operated since 2001, Cardinal Self Storage provides numerous secure storage units that can meet all clients' needs. It is strategically situated off Interstate 69, and customers can easily access it. Besides being fenced, the company has implemented multiple security measures such as surveillance cameras and a computerized gate. Its convenience features include paved aisles, drive-up access, and extra-wide driveways. This location has all metal buildings and is well-lit. Tenants can get month-to-month leases. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

“Very clean, owners are awesome! If you need a storage unit, I would highly recommend Cardinal!”

Go Store It

1823 East 53rd Street Anderson, IN 46013

Located on East 53rd Street, Go Store It is easily accessible via Interstate 69 by students, business owners, and residents seeking storage solutions. All units are ground level, so renters don’t struggle with stairs or elevators. Some are climate-controlled to prevent cold and heat from affecting the goods. This location has covered outdoor parking spots for storing seasonal vehicles. Video surveillance is available to monitor the building 24/7, and the aisles are well-lighted. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

I've had a storage unit there for over 10 years and never had a problem. They have temperature-controlled units and outdoor units. Very pleased.

Great Value Storage

3380 N Post Road Indianapolis, IN 46226

Great Value Storage provides flexible options ranging from standard to drive-up units to meet clients' business, personal, and vehicle storage needs. This property is fenced and gated and has on-site video cameras and a resident manager to ensure the safety of tenants' items. The company's website offers an online payment option that allows customers to make their payments conveniently. Customers can enjoy month-to-month leases, and parking spaces for cars, RVs, and boats are available. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

“I have not had any issues at all. The manager and associates are always very helpful and reasonable. Thank you for your service!”

Hwy 32 Self Storage

4570 W State Road 32 Anderson, IN 46011

Hwy 32 Self Storage makes the moving process simple by offering safe and clean units. The climate-controlled storage units protect renters' goods from Indiana's intense humidity and temperatures. Clients can access their belongings 24/7 using a personal gate code, and they don't have to worry about security because modern video surveillance cameras monitor the facility. A spacious parking area is also available to accommodate cars, boats, and RVs. Online payments are allowed, as well. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

“I rented from them for two years!! Service was always great, no issue, the unit price has never gone up for me either!”

Marstall's Storage

2156 E CR 100 N Anderson, IN 46012

Marstall's Storage has the perfect units for businesses, residents, and students needing a safe space to store their office, household, or school items. Its friendly professionals guide tenants in finding a suitable unit for their needs. This location is well-lit and features perimeter fencing and a keypad-accessible gate for additional safety. Renters have 24-hour access to their belongings and pay rent online. They can also park their RVs, cars, or business vans on location. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

“Don is always a very pleasant, helpful man. We have had a great experience at Marstall’s storage.”

Port-A-Stor

2500 South Fletcher Street Anderson, IN 46016

Port-A-Stor helps commercial and residential clients with their storage, moving, and temporary office space needs. The company's innovative approach involves delivering a portable container to clients’ job sites, homes, or businesses, allowing them to load and arrange their valuables at their own pace. Customers can keep their portable units at their locations or store them at the company's secure and temperature-controlled facility. Clients are served by an experienced staff that gets the job done efficiently. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Gary runs a very reputable business. If you need portable storage units here in Madison County, give Port-A-Stor a call. You won't be disappointed.

Prime Storage

Multiple Locations

Conveniently accessible via Interstate 69, Prime Storage provides clean units for residents and businesses. Clients can access an array of unit sizes, climate-controlled or standard, ranging from 5x5 to 25x25. Vans and trucks can access this property because of the wide aisles. This location has covered parking units perfect for boat, RV, or trailer storage. Renters enjoy convenient features such as ground-level and drive-up access. Also, the units are well-lit. Units are accessible 24/7. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

“Thank goodness they were able to fill my needs for a large climate-controlled unit. Check-in was speedy and efficient.”

Public Storage

Multiple Locations

Public Storage provides units in various sizes to meet its clients' business, personal, and vehicle needs. The climate-controlled units keep renters' stuff within the required humidity or temperature range. At this facility, all rentals are month-to-month, and no credit card is required. The staff at this location is friendly, and renters can access their goods daily from 6 a.m. to 9 p.m. The facility is well-lit and has a free parking space. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

“The service was awesome! Very friendly staff! Breath of fresh air! I will recommend this company to family and friends.”

SE Storage

700 West 53rd Street Anderson, IN 46013

SE Storage provides a stress-free self-storage experience for residents and business owners. With wide-ranging units available on site, tenants can find the right type and size for their items. The facility’s 24/7 online bill pay and rentals make the customer experience quick and easy. Security measures include on-site security personnel and digital video surveillance to help keep tenants’ items safe. Additional features entail 24-hour access, climate control, and drive-up access. RV and boat parking is available. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

“Loved the automation and ease of access. I signed up online, paid bills online, and got access to units. Wow! the 21st Century has arrived!”

Simply Self Storage

Multiple Locations

Individuals seeking storage solutions can easily access Simply Self Storage through major roadways, including Highway 421 and Allisonville Road. The units are available from 5x5 to 10x20. This building has ample security features, including keypad entry, bright lighting, video cameras, and a secure fence to keep the tenants’ belongings safe. Clients benefit from the convenient drive-up units, and they can purchase packing supplies at this location. This company also offers boat and vehicle parking and climate-controlled units. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

“Doug was very helpful and knowledgeable. Smooth and simple process. Trust in leaving my things in the care of this facility and crew 100 percent!”

Snapbox Self Storage - Conner Street

Multiple Locations

Businesses and homeowners searching for climate-controlled units for rent can easily access Snapbox Self Storage - Conner Street via State Roads 37 and 38. Its units have drive-up access so renters can pull up directly in front. The building is fully fenced and has surveillance cameras to make sure renters’ properties are safe. Its management offers contactless rentals. Clients can enjoy the month-to-month rent and daily rental access from 6 a.m. to 10 p.m. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

“Awesome customer service! Great and lowest prices!!!! A reliable staff, which is a very important aspect for me!”

Storage Express

Multiple Locations

Storage Express is easily accessible by businesses and homeowners seeking storage solutions because it is situated right off Interstate 69, off County Road 100 W. It has various units ranging from 5x10 to 10x30 for homeowners who are downsizing, relocating, or renovating. Multiple security options, including 24/7 video surveillance, individualized gate codes, fencing, and bright lighting, ensure the safety of tenants’ items. Customers can access their goods daily. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

“The whole process was very easy to use online for renting, and I received everything via email. The unit was clean and easy to access.”

Storage of America LLC

Multiple Locations

Storage of America LLC has units in a variety of sizes that the community members can use for their storage needs. Its well-maintained, climate-controlled spaces protect clients’ sensitive items from harsh weather conditions. The building is fully secured with video cameras and has drive-up units, making loading and unloading easier. Tenants rent on a month-to-month basis and can purchase boxes and bubble wraps. Complimentary carts are also available at this location. Other convenience features include 24-hour kiosks. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

“The manager was extremely friendly and very helpful. She went out of her way to make the experience better for us.”

Storage Rentals of America

Multiple Locations

Storage Rentals of America has a knowledgeable customer service team that can walk clients’ through the rental process over the phone, helping them find the right-size unit for their items. Tenants can store their fragile items securely using the climate-controlled units. They are also offered month-to-month leases and can pay online. At this location, renters can find parking for a trailer, an RV, a boat, and a car. The building is well-lit and has video cameras. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Kristen was very nice and polite to work with. She made the move-in process extremely smooth and effortless.

StorageMart

Multiple Locations

StorageMart offers drive-up accessible units providing customers with the ultimate convenience when loading and unloading their items. Its flexible monthly leasing makes renting the space easy, and no deposit is required. Renters with sensitive items vulnerable to extreme freezing or heat can benefit from the facility’s temperature-controlled storage units. They can easily rent a unit online and are offered complimentary moving carts. Additional amenities include a gated entry, elevator access, and a drive-in loading bay. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

“Renting here’s pretty awesome! It’s clean, and the managers are really friendly, and easy to get to at any time! I highly recommend this place.”

The Cost of Self Storage in Anderson, IN

The average costs of storage units in Anderson are below the state and national averages for the most common storage unit sizes. Storage unit costs will vary depending on the various amenities the facility offers, so shop around to make sure you’re only paying for what you need.

The average cost of storage units in Anderson compared to state and national averages
Size of Storage Unit City Average State Average National Average
5×5 $14 $35 $41
5×10 $34 $52 $59
10×10 $58 $76 $95
10×15 $87 $94 $114
10×20 $110 $108 $133