Best Self Storage Units in Fishers, Indiana of 2023
In order to pick the top 22 storage units companies in Fishers, we looked at all 209 facilities in the area, including an in-depth review of each company’s amenities, features, and customer reviews.
Our Picks
-
Affordable Family Storage -
Ameri-Stor Self Storage
-
CubeSmart Self Storage
-
Downtown Indy Self Storage
-
Extra Space Storage
-
Geist Self Storage
-
Global Self Storage
-
Harbour Storage
-
Infinite Self Storage
-
Prime Storage
-
Public Storage
-
SecurCare Self-Storage
-
Signature Self Storage
-
Simply Self Storage
-
Snapbox Self Storage
-
Storage Express
-
Storage of America
-
Storage Rentals of America
-
StorageMart
-
Store Space Self Storage
-
StorQuest Economy
-
U-STOR Self Storage
Our Selection Criteria
Our goal is to connect people with the best local storage facilities. We analyzed every single storage facility in the area and rated them based on 30 different variables to pick the best storage unit facilities in Fishers.
-
209Facilities Reviewed
-
119Facilities Curated
-
22Top Picks
-
1. Customer Service
A record of outstanding customer reviews and service.
-
2. Amenities
Offers the most important features popular with customers.
-
3. Location
Multiple nearby facilities for maximum convenience.
-
4. Professionalism
A reputation of honest and reliable business practices.
The 22 Best Storage Facilities in Fishers
Affordable Family Storage
10901 E Washington Street Indianapolis, IN 46229Conveniently located in the Centre East shopping area, Affordable Family Storage features climate-controlled units ranging in size from 25 to 200 square feet. Deluxe units are located closer to elevators, entrances, and multiple doors for easier access. Security amenities include interior/exterior lighting, 24-hour video surveillance, gated entry, and on-site managers. Locks can be purchased on-site, and customers can access their belongings from 6 a.m. to 10 p.m. daily.
Ameri-Stor Self Storage
8023 N 600 W McCordsville, IN 46055Conveniently located off of Mt. Comfort Road near McCordsville Town Hall, Ameri-Stor Self Storage was established in 2008. The facility offers climate-controlled and traditional units of various sizes for personal belongings and business supplies. Parking spaces for boats, trailers, RVs, and vehicles are available. Wide driveways offer easy entry and exit. The fully fenced property features gated keypads for entry, security cameras, cylinder locks, and routine patrols by staff members. Customers can make payments online.
CubeSmart Self Storage
2135 N Illinois Street Indianapolis, IN 46202Located near Interstate 65 and Circle Centre Mall, CubeSmart Self Storage serves residents in the Indianapolis area. Customers can choose from a variety of climate-controlled and drive-up-accessible units ranging in size from 25 to 200 square feet. The multilevel facility features sufficient interior/exterior lighting, 24-hour video surveillance, gated entry, and elevator access. Tenants have access to a moving truck, handcarts, and dollies. For customer convenience, reservations and rent payments can be made online.
Downtown Indy Self Storage
1233 W 18th Street Indianapolis, IN 46202Downtown Indy Self Storage is located in the heart of Indianapolis near several main freeways, the company offers interior, climate-controlled units of various sizes. The multilevel facility is fully fenced, utilizes keypad entry, and monitors activity with security surveillance. Customers can access their belongings from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m., Monday through Friday, and from 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. on weekends. Unit reservations and bill payments can be made online.
Extra Space Storage
Extra Space Storage is located within two miles of the Indianapolis Airport. It offers ground-floor units from 50 to 300 square feet. There are climate-controlled rentals with drive-up access. It also has enclosed spaces for vehicles. Security features include video surveillance and individual alarms to protect each unit. The facility accommodates large vehicles with wide aisles and is ADA-compliant. Facility entry is available 24/7 with manager approval. Storage choices include budget-friendly options.
Geist Self Storage
11575 Fox Road Indianapolis, IN 46236Located near the communities of Geist Valley Estates and Admiral's Cove, Geist Self Storage provides local residents with affordable units. Professional on-site staff can help customers choose from a variety of options, including drive-up and climate-controlled units. The fully fenced facility features exterior/interior lighting and camera surveillance for enhanced security. Customers have 24-hour access to their belongings, and a free truck rental is available by appointment. Rent can be paid online.
Global Self Storage
13942 E 96th Street McCordsville, IN 46055Global Self Storage is a locally owned business serving the McCordsville community. Customers can choose from climate-controlled spaces, drive-up access units, and parking for vehicles, boats and RVs. Units range in size from 15 to 990 square feet. Security features include 24-hour video monitoring, motion-detecting lights, perimeter gates, and keypad entry. Wide driveways provide convenient loading and unloading, and packing supplies can be bought on-site. Reservations and payments can be made online.
Harbour Storage
20236 Hague Road Noblesville, IN 46062Located near downtown Noblesville, Harbour Storage is a family-owned business offering rental solutions for personal and commercial belongings. Units vary in size from 30 to 900 square feet. Select units have climate controls or drive-up access, and outdoor parking is available for boats and RVs. Larger units include electrical outlets. The well-lit, fully fenced facility features 24-hour video surveillance and keypad gated entry. Tenants have 24-hour access to their belongings, and bills can be paid online.
Infinite Self Storage
550 W Carmel Avenue Carmel, IN 46032Infinite Self Storage offers clean units ranging in size from 25 to 600 square feet. Both standard and climate-controlled spaces are available. Customers can rent a month-to-month unit without a security deposit. It offers around-the-clock access with 24/7 security. There are cylinder locks for sale for additional unit protection. The facility is well-lit, and wide aisles make maneuvering easy. It provides moving supplies for purchase and on-site management for hands-on help.
Prime Storage
12650 Ford Drive Fishers, IN 46038Prime Storage has standard and climate-controlled units from 25 to 300 square feet. Customers can reserve a month-to-month rental without a credit card. There is 24-hour phone support and around-the-clock access to storage units. A gated fence protects the building, and individual locks are for sale. It provides wide aisles and brightly lit walkways for easy maneuvering. Moving supplies are available for purchase. Hours of operation are from 6 a.m. to 9 p.m. daily.
Public Storage
Public Storage provides units from 25 to 300 square feet. Rentals are available month-to-month, and reservations do not require a credit card. Customers can choose climate-controlled units to protect sensitive items. There are large-size spaces with drive-up access for loading and unloading convenience. It offers secure storage by keypad entry and daily gate hours from 6 a.m. to 9 p.m. Office staff is available seven days a week.
SecurCare Self-Storage
SecurCare Self-Storage has a variety of small to large-size units from 25 to 600 square feet. It offers standard and climate-controlled units with drive-up access and also has outdoor spots for vehicles, boats, and RVs. Customers can manage their accounts and month-to-month leases online. It provides on-site supplies to assist with moving-related needs. The premises feature around-the-clock video surveillance with fencing and a gate to keep belongings safe. Rental insurance is available.
Signature Self Storage
8050 Ortho Lane Brownsburg, IN 46112Located just west of Highway 267 near many residential communities, Signature Self Storage is a locally owned company serving residents and businesses in the Brownsburg area. The facility has climate-controlled and drive-up units, and outdoor parking is available for vehicles, boats, and RVs. Safety amenities include security surveillance, keypad gate access, high-security cylinder locks, and perimeter fences. Tenants have access to moving carts, and packing supplies can be purchased at the office.
Simply Self Storage
Simply Self Storage provides climate-controlled units from 25 to 300 square feet. Its rentals have drive-up access for easy unloading and loading of personal items. Storage is also available for vehicles and boats. Bright lights and around-the-clock security cameras surround the facility. A keypad code controls unit access. Business hours are Monday through Friday from 9:30 a.m. to 6 p.m. and Saturdays from 8:30 a.m. to 5 p.m.
Snapbox Self Storage
Snapbox Self Storage offers drive-up storage spaces from 10 to 300 square feet. Customers can reserve a month-to-month rental without a credit card. It has room to accommodate vehicles, boats, and RVs. Security cameras within the fenced property keep belongings secure. It offers a contact-free rental process and customer support through phone, text, and live chat. The facility is open seven days a week from 6 a.m. to 10 p.m.
Storage Express
Storage Express provides rental spaces from 25 to 300 square feet. There are climate-controlled, drive-up, and interior-access units for rent. Customers can make payments by phone, mail, or online. Well-lit premises and around-the-clock video monitoring offer tenant and item protection. The company provides renters with complimentary disc locks for extra security. In addition, customers can purchase storage insurance at affordable rates. Facility hours are from 6 a.m. to 10 p.m. daily.
Storage of America
8805 Pendleton Pike Lawrence, IN 46226Storage of America is a family-owned company conveniently located in the business district near Highway 465. Ground floor and drive-up units are available for personal belongings and commercial needs. The fully fenced property is regularly maintained and monitored with 24-hour camera surveillance. Gate hours are from 6 a.m. to 9 p.m. daily. On-site staff can provide assistance as needed, and reservations and payments can be made through the online portal.
Storage Rentals of America
20250 Hague Road Noblesville, IN 46062Storage Rentals of America serves Noblesville and the surrounding communities. Conveniently located near Highway 19, the facility offers climate-controlled units in an array of sizes for commercial and residential belongings. Parking spaces are available for RVs, boats, and vehicles. Units with drive-up access and wide aisles allow easy entry and exit. The fully fenced facility is monitored with 24-hour video surveillance and accessible with an electronic gated keypad. Customers can purchase moving supplies and locks on-site.
StorageMart
Conveniently located near I-69, StorageMart features units from 25 to 300 square feet. Customers can manage their accounts online and reserve storage without paying a security fee. It offers standard and climate-controlled rentals. There is drive-up, elevator, and handcart access for move-in assistance. Facility hours are 6 a.m. to 10 p.m. daily. StorageMart provides 24-hour phone support, and the accepted forms of payment include cash, checks, Visa, AMEX, and Discover.
Store Space Self Storage
Store Space Self Storage offers standard drive-up units from 72 to 518 square feet. There is no security fee for its month-to-month rentals. It also has safe indoor storage for vehicles, RVs, and boats. Lighted paths and digital surveillance provide security throughout the property. Handcarts and packing supplies for purchase help manage customer moves. Military members and veterans receive 10% off. There is daily unit access from 6 a.m. to 10 p.m.
StorQuest Economy
3380 N Post Road Indianapolis, IN 46226StorQuest Economy is a locally owned business serving residents of Indianapolis and nearby communities. Conveniently located minutes from Interstate 465, this gated facility has a variety of climate-controlled units available for personal and commercial belongings, as well as parking spaces for vehicles, boats and RVs. Safety features include 24-hour digital video surveillance, gated entry, and exterior lighting around the property. Month-to-month rentals are available, and customers can manage their accounts online.
U-STOR Self Storage
U-STOR Self Storage offers rentals from 50 to 300 square feet. All units feature 24-hour drive-up access and individual alarms. It has a gated and brick-constructed facility. There is video surveillance and on-duty management for ground security. The company provides helpful service and convenient storage at competitive prices. Business hours are Monday through Friday from 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. and Saturdays from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m.
The Cost of Self Storage in Fishers, IN
The average costs of storage units in Fishers are above the state and national averages for the most common storage unit sizes. Storage unit costs will vary depending on the various amenities the facility offers, so shop around to make sure you’re only paying for what you need.
| The average cost of storage units in Fishers compared to state and national averages | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Size of Storage Unit | City Average | State Average | National Average |
| 5×5 | $29 | $35 | $41 |
| 5×10 | $61 | $52 | $59 |
| 10×10 | $86 | $76 | $95 |
| 10×15 | $121 | $94 | $114 |
| 10×20 | $146 | $108 | $133 |