Best Self Storage Units in Middletown, NY

In order to pick the top 13 storage units companies in Middletown, we looked at all 124 facilities in the area, including an in-depth review of each company’s amenities, features, and customer reviews.

Our Selection Criteria

Our goal is to connect people with the best local storage facilities. We analyzed every single storage facility in the area and rated them based on 30 different variables to pick the best storage unit facilities in Middletown.

  • shape-1 124
    Facilities Reviewed
  • shape-1 71
    Facilities Curated
  • shape-1 13
    Top Picks
  • 1. Reputation

    A history of great customer reviews and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

The 13 Best Storage Facilities in Middletown

Show Map

Albany Post Self Storage

2377 Albany Post Road Walden, NY 12586

Albany Post Self Storage offers clean and easily accessible storage unit rentals for clients in the area surrounding the Village of Walden and the Town of Montgomery. Since 2001, it has been providing ground-level units at competitive and pocket-friendly rates without any hidden or administrative fees. Over the years, the facility’s management has been dedicated to improving how customers rent out the units. Currently, clients in need of indoor storage compartments and outdoor parking spaces for RVs and automotive items such as jet skis, boats and motorcycles can rent a storage space conveniently and remotely via the facility’s website. In terms of access, the staff is available from 7 a.m. to 10 p.m. from Monday to Sunday. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Some reviewers praise the facility for its big units. One customer’s review said, “Very big units." Another long-term client remarked, “I was able to find lowest priced storage at Albany Post Self Storage. It really meets my storage needs.”

All Season's Self Storage

391 Highland Avenue Exterior Middletown, NY 10940

All Season's Self Storage is a locally owned and operated self-storage facility that prides itself on providing well-maintained units that serve both residential and commercial storage needs. It offers climate-controlled indoor spaces available in 5x5, 10x10 and 5x12 sizes as well as dry storage options ranging between 10x10 and 10x30 square feet. For customers in need of storage spaces for cars, motorcycles, recreational vehicles, and commercial equipment or supplies, the facility offers secure outdoor storage options. In security matters, its friendly storage professionals provide locks and utilize video surveillance technology to keep a watchful eye over the customer's property. The facility has computerized access systems and superior lighting to guarantee maximum safety and ease of navigation around-the-clock. Additional convenience perks include 24-hour access to units. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers love that the facility is well-maintained and how the management is always keen on providing reasonably priced units. One reviewer noted, "Friendly experience dealing with Mike, and it was a quick easy process. He was very professional and informative. Great place to store your staff and very reasonable. The facility is very clean and well-maintained. I would highly recommend."

Beehive Self Storage

155 Bracken Road Montgomery, NY 12549

Beehive Self Storage is a storage facility in Montgomery that’s conveniently located a short distance from the Stewart International Airport and close to the intersection of Route 17K and Route 208. It provides the residents of Rock Tavern, Walden, Maybrook and Newburgh with 24-hour, handicap and drive-up accessible units ranging between 5x10 and 15x30 square feet. The management also provides access to separate units uniquely designed to serve the storage needs of contractors. Apart from having all-round perimeter fencing and electronic gate systems accessible through individual passcodes, the facility has 24-hour video surveillance cameras that watch over the customer’s belongings. Security is further guaranteed by bright lighting fixtures that have been installed throughout the property. Other than discounted rates for military servicemen and women, the facility offers adequate parking spaces for recreational vehicles and boats. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers enjoy how the friendly staff strives to fully satisfy the client’s storage desires. One reviewer noted, “Manager was very personable. He recommended a small unit that met my needs perfectly. He did not try to over sell me. The unit was spotless, dry and warm. Highly recommend this facility. It is very secure with cameras and gate entry.”

Carriage House Self Storage

25 Hathorn Road Warwick, NY 10990

Carriage House Self Storage is a full-service storage facility offering both climate-controlled and dry storage solutions. With hundreds of storage compartments onsite, customers can enjoy 5x5 spaces, enough for the contents of a single room, along with large 10x30 units that can conveniently house items from eight to 10 rooms. The office is open from Monday to Friday between 9 a.m. 5 p.m., but access to the units is acceptable at any time of day or night. A computerized gate access system upholds security and individual unit locks purchasable on location. For convenience, the facility’s competitive rates are payable monthly, making it a convenient solution for clients with short-term storage needs. Also, self-storage clients at the facility can access boxes and moving supplies upon request as well as renter’s insurance if they have none. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Previous customers show a high level of appreciation for the convenient self-storage experience they get at Carriage House Self Storage. One reviewer said, “A most wonderful place!!! Owners are extremely helpful and willing to work with us. We had the storage unit for three years and would highly recommend the Carriage House. Even though my daughter’s belongings were in an outside storage bin, everything was in very good condition and the owners were just as nice at the end as they were in the beginning. A very pleasant experience!”

CubeSmart Self Storage

Multiple Locations

CubeSmart Self Storage is a gated self-storage facility located in an easily accessible location within Middletown. It offers flexible gate access hours to its climate-controlled and drive-up accessible storage units. Sized between 5x5 and 10x20 square feet, the units are protected by perimeter fencing, an onsite manager, superior lighting and 24-hour video surveillance cameras. The helpful storage professionals on staff also avail affordable insurance options to ensure speedy replacement of the client’s belongings in the event of a tragedy. Additionally, they provide moving labor assistance along with boxes and moving supplies to guarantee a pleasant and hassle-free moving experience. Discounts are also available, and clients with short-term storage needs can benefit from monthly lease agreements. Besides that, both the ground-level and elevator accessible units can be paid for remotely using the facility’s online payment resource. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

The majority of online reviews describe the facility as a great storage facility with the word “excellent” often coming up. Specifically, one happy client said, “Great storage facility and great storage unit. Great location.”

DolsonTown Road Self Storage

1168 Dolsontown Road Middletown, NY 1094

DolsonTown Road Self Storage is a convenient self-storage option located just off of Rt. 84, and it serves clients in Middletown and the surrounding communities. Offering affordable month-to-month lease contracts, the facility has dry storage units as well as accessible drive-up spaces ranging between 25 square feet, the size of a conventional closet locker, and 300 square feet, enough to fit the contents of a five to seven-bedroom house. Additionally, the facility is gated and equipped with all-round perimeter fencing, bright lights and security surveillance cameras to guarantee maximum security. Furthermore, the professional and welcoming storage crew provides each individual with a personal keypad access code to the gate. That way, they can visit their unit without having to make prior arrangements. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Some positive reviews refer to the facility as “great” and describe it as a “clean location.” One five-star reviewer also commends the facility’s 24-hour access saying, “It’s a 24-hour access place well-priced.”

Fort Knox Self Storage

Multiple Locations

Fort Knox Self Storage offers convenient, affordable and comprehensive storage solutions for homeowners who need to free up some space in the garage and small and large-scale businesses looking for somewhere to store their inventories and outdated financial records. With a focus on commercial clients, the facility provides access to a wide range of climate-controlled unit sizes accessible through monthly lease agreements. That aside, the facility’s management has invested substantially into the security infrastructure. The client’s property is under the constant surveillance of CCTV cameras, and the staff proactively conducts perimeter checks regularly to prevent security breaches via the perimeter fencing. Additional security features include burglar alarms, individual unit locks, security checkpoints, and fire suppression systems. The storage units can be accessed at any time of day or night. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

The facility’s online reviews indicate that customers consider it to be affordable. Customers also appreciate the exceptional customer service offered by various members of its friendly staff. One reviewer said, “Awesome customer service,” and another noted, “Nice people, very reasonable priced storage.”

Guardian Self Storage

Multiple Locations

Guardian Self Storage is a self-storage facility positioned within a visually appealing property located between Warwick and Sugarloaf's charming villages. Seated just 2 miles north of Warwick Village, the facility offers a vast selection of storage unit sizes equipped with electric power outlets as well as temperature control and drive-up accessibility features. The climate-controlled units range between 40 and 154 square feet, enabling proper shielding of sensitive items regardless of their size. The facility's management provides 24-hour access to the units and convenient monthly leasing options with no deposit required. Furthermore, it offers moving supplies such as disc locks, bubble wrap, tape, mattress bags, packing paper and moving blankets at pocket-friendly rates. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Words such as "great facility" and "very professional and thorough" come up in the facility's online reviews. One reviewer said, "I have rented bad storage and good storage. You wouldn't think it would be that difficult but it is. Anita runs a great facility for Guardian. Well-maintained, clean, friendly service, no baloney. Just simply great."

iStorage Middletown

295 Ballard Road Middletown, NY 10941

Located near Galleria at Crystal Run, just north of Crystal Run Healthcare, iStorage Middletown is a convenient self-storage facility serving the residents of Middletown, Michigan Corners, Washington Heights and Scotchtown. The facility has state-of-the-art storage units available in a wide range of sizes, from 5x5 to 20x20 square feet, to adequately satisfy both residential and commercial storage needs. Some of the units’ convenience features include indoor and drive-up accessibility as well as temperature-controlled storage and top-tier security components. Apart from an on-site manager, the customer’s property is kept safe with the help of 24-hour video surveillance cameras and electronic gate access. Additionally, the facility is fully fenced with each unit having individual alarms. Bright lights have been installed throughout the property to further tighten the security and to ease navigation during the extended access hours. Customers can also consult with the onsite manager when in need of round-the-clock access to their units. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers use words such as “excellent facility” and “great prices and awesome service” when reviewing the facility online. One such review read, “I can’t get over how clean the facility is. Much cleaner than other facilities that I’ve seen. Ladies keep up the good work.”

Life Storage - Middletown

Multiple Locations

Life Storage - Middletown is a facility located on Industrial Drive, southeast of the NY-17 Highway between Georges Road and Fortune Road W and in proximity to Silver Lake. It offers an exceptional storage experience that encompasses access to secure, affordable and climate-controlled units to the residents of Middletown, Washington Heights, Scotchtown and the surrounding communities. Other than temperature control, the facility has ground-level and drive-up accessible units for maximum convenience when moving in or out as well as indoor elevator available storage spaces. The management allows clients to access their compartments around the clock. It utilizes 24-hour video surveillance, superior lighting fixtures and passcode gate entry systems to ensure hassle-free navigation and monitor the client’s belongings constantly. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers appreciate how the storage crew onsite is always willing and ready to help. One happy customer said, “I just want to say this was the best place I’ve ever stored my belongings. In the office, the ladies were approachable, informative and accurate. Thank you so much for a wonderful experience.”

Moove In Self Storage

902 NY-17M Middletown, NY 10940

Located just 3 miles from the northern side of Middletown and one-quarter mile from the intersection of 17M and route 302, Moove In Self Storage is a convenient self-storage facility serving local residents in Washington Heights, Scotchdown and Circleville. On site, clients can access non-temperature controlled and drive-up accessible units ranging from 5x10 to 10x30. They can also use the 10x20 to 10x30 square feet outdoor garage spaces to park their recreational vehicles and automobiles. Apart from the resident manager, stored property is kept safe with the help of an electronic gate with keypad access systems, all-round fencing, 24/7 video surveillance, superior lighting and purchasable locks available upon request. Other convenience features incorporate online account management options, wide drive aisles to facilitate truck access and the availability of free dollies and carts to help with loading and unloading. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

The facility receives loads of positive remarks from both previous and current clients. One happy reviewer said, “Friendly service and fair pricing. I’m one happy customer! Need storage… Moove In Self Storage is the place to go!!”

Prime Storage

1021 Dolsontown Road Middletown, NY 10940

The Prime Storage facility on Dolsontown Road in Middletown is a one-stop-shop for storage services that offers ground-level and drive-up accessible storage units in various sizes. It has small 5x5 square foot units ideally designed to store extra items such as gardening tools, office supplies and miscellaneous items as well as larger 10x30 compartments, perfect for keeping entertainment centers, beds and couches. The facility permits access to the units during extended hours throughout the week with the possibility of requesting 24-hour access when necessary. For security, the hospitable storage crew relies on 24-hour video surveillance technology and the fact that the facility has all-round wall fencing. During move-ins, customers can rent the moving van onsite and purchase boxes and moving supplies if need be. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

The majority of customers are thankful for the exceptional services offered by the facility and its management. One satisfied reviewer noted, “I have been a tenant of Capital Self Storage/Prime Storage for more than 15 years. I own a small business and park my trucks at their facility and also rent a storage unit at this facility for my equipment and tools. The staff Anthony and Skyler are so friendly, helpful and kind to me and all tenants at Pride Storage… Both of these gentlemen are true assets to your organization.”

StorageTown

Multiple Locations

StorageTown is a storage solutions provider that strives to comprehensively satisfy the storage needs of clients in Middletown, Goshen and Wallkill. Whether the client needs long-term storage for business inventories and documents or short-term storage following a temporary move, the facility provides well-preserved units with individual door alarms. Available in 5x10 to 10x30 sizes, the units are secured with the help of a pin-code activated gate and surveillance video cameras that operate throughout the day. Apart from having 9-foot ceilings, all the units are on the ground level, hence simplifying the process of moving in or out. That aside, the storage professionals on staff provide moving supplies such as mattress and dust covers, boxes and packing tape to enhance the client’s storage experience. It also has outdoor parking for recreational automobiles and boats. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers are pleased with the facility’s level of customer service and convenience features. A review from a happy client said, “Spacious driveways for loading and unloading, well-maintained buildings that are accessible everyday from 6am to 8 pm. Rental fees are on par with all the others that are in that area, and they have good staff. So if you ever find yourself in the need of extra storage space I would definitely recommend checking out StorageTown for all your needs.”

The Cost of Self Storage in Middletown, NY

The average costs of storage units in Middletown are on par with the state and national averages for the most common storage unit sizes. Storage unit costs will vary depending on the various amenities the facility offers, so shop around to make sure you’re only paying for what you need.

The average cost of storage units in Middletown compared to state and national averages
Size of Storage Unit City Average State Average National Average
5×5 $63 $52 $41
5×10 $74 $86 $59
10×10 $100 $140 $95
10×15 $164 $176 $114
10×20 $189 $164 $133