Best Self Storage Units in Garden City, New York of 2022

In order to pick the top 16 storage units companies in Garden City, we looked at all 152 facilities in the area, including an in-depth review of each company’s amenities, features, and customer reviews.

Our Selection Criteria

Our goal is to connect people with the best local storage facilities. We analyzed every single storage facility in the area and rated them based on 30 different variables to pick the best storage unit facilities in Garden City.

  • shape-1 152
    Facilities Reviewed
  • shape-1 87
    Facilities Curated
  • shape-1 16
    Top Picks
  • 1. Customer Service

    A record of outstanding customer reviews and service.

  • 2. Amenities

    Offers the most important features popular with customers.

  • 3. Location

    Multiple nearby facilities for maximum convenience.

  • 4. Professionalism

    A reputation of honest and reliable business practices.

The 16 Best Storage Facilities in Garden City

Hide Map

Central Self Storage

4055 Austin Boulevard Island Park, NY 11558

Central Self Storage offers convenient and affordable storage solutions to commercial and residential customers throughout the area. Located less than an hour from JFK International Airport, it provides small, medium-sized, and large storage units, including climate-controlled spaces to help protect items from temperature fluctuations. Customers can rent a truck, use dollies and carts, and purchase a variety of moving and packing supplies on-site. For ultimate flexibility, renters have 24-hour access to their units. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

[Staff member] Tom was so helpful in our selection of a storage unit. He was very knowledgeable, professional and very kind.

CubeSmart Self Storage

Multiple Locations

CubeSmart Self Storage is conveniently located on 47th Avenue and serves both residential and commercial customers with their storage needs. It has a variety of units available, from 5' x 5' to 10' x 20'. It also offers many accessibility options, including elevator and first-floor access. Tenants can use the truck provided by the company free of charge to move their belongings hassle-free. Active duty military personnel can receive a discount. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

From my first call to find the right unit through to signing my lease and moving in, I've been very impressed by the helpfulness and professionalism.

Extra Space Storage

1 Herricks Road Garden City Park, NY 11040

Extra Space Storage is conveniently located just off Rockaway Avenue and Old Country Road and in the proximity of both Adelphi University and Hofstra University. It has a wide range of storage units, from as small as 4' x 5' to as large as 22' x 55'. Security measures include video surveillance, electronic gate access, and individual alarms. Customers have access to their belongings seven days a week from 6 a.m. to 10 p.m. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

It was my first time renting a storage space. The staff was very helpful and made things super easy. [It] was easy to find and very clean.

Freeport Self Storage

73 East Merrick Road Freeport, NY 11520

Freeport Self Storage is a family-owned and operated facility that has been serving commercial and residential customers in the area since 1997. Some units have drive-up access, which allows for easy transporting of items, and the premises are kept secure with a network of high-definition surveillance cameras operating 24/7. The company accepts a variety of payment methods, including electronic payments via the website and mobile app and automatic credit card payments. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

I absolutely love Freeport Self Storage. They are professional, and the facility is great. [It's] dry and cool, not humid. It is clean and access is just great.

GoodFriend Self Storage New Hyde Park

119 S 3rd Street New Hyde Park, NY 11040

GoodFriend Self Storage New Hyde Park offers a large selection of modern, safe, and secure storage units to rent for both residential and commercial customers. Its premises are open every day of the week and protected with 24/7 video surveillance, with digital backup in case of an emergency. New renters can use the free rental truck to make transporting their items free of hassle. For those with temperature-sensitive belongings, there are climate-controlled units available. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

GoodFriend Self-Storage of New Hyde Park is an awesome facility. [It] exceeded expectations. It’s clean, organized, well lit, and has a very convenient layout.

Life Storage

Multiple Locations

Life Storage has a large selection of storage units available, from 5' x 5' to 10' x 30'. Customers can also opt for climate-controlled units to protect their sensitive items from extreme temperatures. The company's premises are well-lit and fenced to prevent unauthorized people from entering, and 24/7 surveillance cameras are positioned throughout the facility. Multiple payment options are available, and rent is calculated on a month-to-month basis to avoid unnecessarily long commitments. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Overall, Life Storage has been very pleasant, and I love that I have 24 hours access, which works nicely with my work.

Moving Ahead

101 Fifth Avenue Garden City Park, NY 11040

Since it was founded in 1983, Moving Ahead has been serving residential and commercial customers in the area with top-quality moving and storing services. It offers both long-term and temporary overnight storage. To add a layer of security, Moving Ahead offers a 24-hour security system, video surveillance cameras, and a modern sprinkler structure. Packing services for moves small or big are also available. Customers can request an estimate online. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

They more than lived up to the hype. Professional, courteous, and great all-around guys to work with.

National Archives Inc.

605 Locust Street Garden City, NY 11530

National Archives Inc. specializes in data and document storage services, and it primarily serves commercial customers. The document storage area is fully climate-controlled, and there is also a data disaster recovery plan available in case of an emergency. All business documents are tracked using computerized barcoding technology, and file descriptions are stored in the database. It also provides electronic access to hard-copy files, pickup and delivery, document shredding, and document imaging. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Working with the National Archives could not be easier or more pleasant. Everyone there is very helpful, and we feel secure storing our documents.

Omega Self Storage

630 Merrick Road Lynbrook, NY 11563

Omega Self Storage is a secure storage facility, available to both residential and commercial customers seven days a week between 6 a.m. and 10 p.m. It offers storage units from very small 5' x 5' to relatively large 10' x 10'. Moving supplies and tenant insurance can be purchased on-site, and payment is accepted in most popular forms, including all major credit cards, cash, checks, and money orders. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

I use it to store my mom's things. The prices are reasonable, and the times that you can access the space are reasonable as well.

Prime Storage

1260 Zerega Avenue Bronx, NY 10462

Prime Storage is committed to helping customers find the right unit for their personal or business needs. Units can be booked online 24/7, and they range from 5' x 5' to 10' x 20'. The facility has many access features, including drive-up units, easy roll-up doors, a covered unloading area, and elevators. There are carts and dollies on-site and, to make the moving process as smooth as possible, renters can use the company's free moving truck to transport their belongings. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

It was very easy making the reservation, and the staff on-site that assisted me was very polite and gave clear detailed information about the company.

Public Storage

1055 Stewart Avenue Garden City, NY 11530

Public Storage is an established company serving commercial and residential customers in the area. To ensure maximum flexibility, it offers both indoor units with hallway access and outdoor drive-up units. For those with temperature-sensitive items, there are climate-controlled units available, and a variety of moving supplies can be purchased at the premises. The facility can be easily reached from Meadowbrook State Parkway, Route 24, Route 25, and Route 102. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

We are long time (10+ years) customers. We have been very happy with the facility the entire time. The building is always kept clean.

Safeguard Self Storage

45 Hempstead Turnpike West Hempstead, NY 11552

Safeguard Self Storage offers customers the utmost security, professional services, and 7-day access to their belongings. The facilities are protected by a network of security cameras, individual unit door alarms, and computer-controlled access to the building and storage area. Carts and dollies are available to use on-site, and customers can purchase a variety of moving and packing supplies. The company calculates rent on a month-to-month basis, so there is no unnecessary commitment involved. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

This facility is well kept, clean, and organized! I will recommend anyone who has any storage needs to please visit this location!

Storage America

211 Denton Avenue New Hyde Park, NY 11040

Located in New Hyde Park and serving all the surrounding areas, Storage America offers secure, clean, and well-maintained storage units for personal and business items, including climate-controlled spaces to help protect customers’ temperature-sensitive items. Tenants can purchase all sorts of supplies when moving in, and the company provides a free move-in truck for a convenient, fast, and flexible experience. Storage units can be booked in advance via Storage America's website. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Great storage facility, high garage doors, very clean, and friendly and helpful staff. They have helped me through this tough time.

Storage Post

1000 Axinn Avenue Garden City, NY 11530

Storage Post boasts a large variety of storage units, friendly staff always eager to help customers, and a plethora of security features for the safety of all stored items. Tenants have 24-hour access to their units. The company utilizes a digital security system with individual access codes, and its climate-controlled units are kept at 78 °F in the summer and 55 °F in the winter to help protect items from temperature damage. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Move-in was super easy. Very accommodating staff with everything you could need for the best prices. This place ticks off everything on my list.

Storage Quarters

999 Stewart Avenue Garden City, NY 11530

Storage Quarters has been serving customers in the area for more than two decades. Tenants can rest assured that their belongings are secure, as the facility is protected with an electronic access gate, 24-hour video surveillance, and keypad entry. The company provides monthly automatic credit card billing, computerized accounts, and a wide selection of moving and packing supplies. In addition, Storage Quarters offers records management, scanning records, and secure document destruction. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

I would definitely recommend it. Great customer service. You can tell they are serious about their business reputation and customer service.

StorQuest Self Storage

401 Railroad Avenue Westbury, NY 11590

Located near the parking lot at Westbury Long Island Train Station, StorQuest Self Storage offers a worry-free storage experience. Its state-of-the-art facility is protected with a network of security cameras and electronic gate access, and it's well-lit with motion-detecting lights. Supplies can be purchased on-site, and there are discounts for seniors and military members. In addition, StorQuest promises to plant one tree for every new storage unit rented. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Easily the best, local storage facility! Highly recommend this facility, great staff, clean and secure.

The Cost of Self Storage in Garden City, NY

The average costs of storage units in Garden City are above the state and national averages for the most common storage unit sizes. Storage unit costs will vary depending on the various amenities the facility offers, so shop around to make sure you’re only paying for what you need.

The average cost of storage units in Garden City compared to state and national averages
Size of Storage Unit City Average State Average National Average
5×5 $55 $52 $41
5×10 $133 $86 $59
10×10 $177 $140 $95
10×15 $253 $176 $114
10×20 $335 $164 $133