Best Self Storage Units in Islip, New York of 2023

In order to pick the top 16 storage units companies in Islip, we looked at all 152 facilities in the area, including an in-depth review of each company’s amenities, features, and customer reviews.

Our Selection Criteria

Our goal is to connect people with the best local storage facilities. We analyzed every single storage facility in the area and rated them based on 30 different variables to pick the best storage unit facilities in Islip.

  • shape-1 152
    Facilities Reviewed
  • shape-1 87
    Facilities Curated
  • shape-1 16
    Top Picks
  • 1. Customer Service

    A record of outstanding customer reviews and service.

  • 2. Amenities

    Offers the most important features popular with customers.

  • 3. Location

    Multiple nearby facilities for maximum convenience.

  • 4. Professionalism

    A reputation of honest and reliable business practices.

The 16 Best Storage Facilities in Islip

Hide Map

America Safe -N- Sound Self-Storage

1800 Prime Place Hauppauge, NY 11788

America Safe -N- Sound Self Storage provides residents and businesses with ground-floor, drive-up units that can be accessed 24 hours a day. The facility is fully gated, alarmed, and equipped with 24-hour video surveillance. The company has gained a reputation for its reasonable rates, quality, and reliance over the years. Customers can also rent moving trucks and cargo, utility, and vehicle trailers to assist them with moving. ...Read More

CubeSmart Self Storage

Multiple Locations

This CubeSmart facility has a range of unit sizes and features that include climate control, drive-up access, and lift access. Customers can also rent parking spaces for RVs and boats on a month-to-month basis. As well as online reservations and payment, customers can use a mobile app to grant access to the facility from 6:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m. daily. Affordable third-party insurance options are available. ...Read More

Extra Space Storage

Multiple Locations

Extra Space Storage's Bay Shore facility offers convenient storage solutions for residents and vehicle owners in the surrounding area. The units are sized between 3x5 and 10x25, with additional outdoor parking spaces to securely store boats, RVs, trailers, and campers. Unit features include climate control, indoor location, and elevator access. Sturdy carts are provided to move heavy items. Access hours are every day from 6:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m. ...Read More

Freeport Self Storage

73 E Merrick Road Freeport, NY 11520

Freeport Self Storage offers a range of convenient features such as online bill payment, drive-up units, and a variety of unit sizes. Customers can rest assured their belongings are safe, thanks to the facility's modern access gate control system, with automatic gates as well as doors, and high definition video surveillance. A free moving truck is provided during move in, and military and senior discounts are available. ...Read More

Life Storage - Islip

Multiple Locations

The units on offer at this Life Storage facility are available in sizes starting at 5x5 and ranging up to 8x28, with climate control to protect belongings from the effects of weather. Customers can reserve and pay for their units online at their convenience. For security, the facility features keypad entry using personal access codes, perimeter fencing, surveillance cameras, and bright lighting throughout the grounds and interior hallways. Extended access hours are available. ...Read More

Metro Self Storage – Oakdale

4038 Sunrise Highway Oakdale, NY 11769

Metro Self Storage is a well-lit, fully fenced facility offering storage units for residential and commercial use and packing supplies for purchase. The units, which can be rented on a monthly basis, come in sizes ranging from 5x5 to 10x50, with parking spaces between 10x15 and 10x40. Security is ensured with electronic gate access and surveillance cameras strategically positioned throughout the property. Access hours are daily from 6:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m. ...Read More

Premier Storage Solutions of West Islip

175 Union Boulevard West Islip, NY 11795

Premier Storage Solutions designed its West Islip facility for convenience, offering features such as 24-hour daily access and boat and RV storage. The units range from 5x5 to 10x35 in size, with options for climate control and drive-up access. Customers have peace of mind knowing their belongings are safe with 24-hour surveillance throughout the facility. Friendly staff is on site to conduct tours, and online bill payment is available. ...Read More

Prime Storage

Multiple Locations

Prime Storage offers convenience through features such as freight elevators, month-to-month leasing, and budget-friendly rates. The units have options including climate control, drive-up locations, and 24-hour access, with outdoor vehicle parking also on offer. The facility is secured with perimeter fencing and electronic gates, and an on-site manager is there to keep an eye on things. Moving supplies and locks are available for purchase. ...Read More

Public Storage

Multiple Locations

With a large range of unit sizes and features to choose from at its Bay Shore location, Public Storage meets all the needs of its residential and commercial customers. Temperature-sensitive items can be stored in climate-controlled units, and bulky items benefit from drive-up access for easy movement. The facility also provides parking and indoor storage for vehicles. For a contactless experience, customers can manage their contracts and unlock the facility's gates using online services. ...Read More

Red Rover Moving & Storage

325 S Technology Drive, Suite A Central Islip, NY 11722

Red Rover is empowering customers with Fetchable Storage, a revolutionary moving and storage solution that saves time and hassle. It allows customers to load their belongings directly onto an 8- or 16-foot portable storage unit which is delivered to their door on a free moving truck. Customers can store their containers at Red Rover's climate-controlled storage center. The weather-resistant units are made of solid steel, with barn-style doors and an industrial-grade locking system. ...Read More

Safeguard Self Storage

Multiple Locations

Safeguard Self Storage features air-conditioned and heated units equipped with individual door alarms and computer-controlled access. A drive-in loading area provides convenience for loading and unloading items. The units range between 5x5 and 10x20 in size, with regular promotions offered online. Boxes and packing supplies can be purchased on site, and deliveries are accepted at the office. Carts and dollies are also available for use. ...Read More

Saint James Mini Storage, Inc.

75 Arlington Avenue Saint James, NY 11780

Saint James Mini Storage is a family owned and operated facility providing climate-controlled and traditional units ranging between 5x5 and 12x22 in size, with drive-up access available. A modern computerized entry system keeps the property secure, allowing customers to use a personalized access code to enter their units. Shelving units are provided for record storage, and boxes and moving supplies are available for purchase on site. The facility is equipped with video surveillance for security. ...Read More

Simply Self Storage

Multiple Locations

Simply Self Storage provides units starting at 5x5 in size, up to 20x15, for rent on a monthly basis, with climate control available as an option. The facility has wide aisles to accommodate moving trucks and a range of packing supplies for sale. Security measures in place include full fencing, bright lighting, camera systems monitoring every angle, and keypad entry. Reservations can be made online, where regular promotions are on offer. ...Read More

Storage Sense

180 Travis Street Lindenhurst, NY 11757

The units at Storage Sense can be rented immediately online, with temperature-controlled units available for sensitive belongings. Outdoor parking spaces can be used to store vehicles, RVs, and boats. Moving supplies are sold on site, where a team of staff are available to assist. Security is assured with 24/7 recording cameras and an electronic gate. Access is available 7 days a week during extended hours. ...Read More

StorQuest Self Storage

Multiple Locations

StorQuest operates a modern, solar-powered facility in Ronkonkoma with 24/7 rentals and support provided. Climate-control units are available to protect items from heat and humidity, and supplies can be purchased on site. Drive-up access and a loading stall make moving in and out more convenient. Advanced digital security measures keep the facility secure, including 24-hour surveillance and electronic gate access. Military and senior discounts are available. ...Read More

U-Haul Storage at Bellemeade Avenue

Multiple Locations

This U-Haul Storage facility offers indoor units ranging between 5x5 and 10x15 in size, and 8x5 U-Box containers for portable storage options. Other services include moving truck sales and rentals, trailer rentals, and the sale of moving supplies. Customers can enjoy the flexibility of month-to-month leases and daily access hours that run from 5:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m., with 24-hour access available on request. Reservations and payments can be made online. ...Read More

The Cost of Self Storage in Islip, NY

The average costs of storage units in Islip are on par with the state and national averages for the most common storage unit sizes. Storage unit costs will vary depending on the various amenities the facility offers, so shop around to make sure you’re only paying for what you need.

The average cost of storage units in Islip compared to state and national averages
Size of Storage Unit City Average State Average National Average
5×5 $31 $52 $41
5×10 $147 $86 $59
10×10 $93 $140 $95
10×15 $136 $176 $114
10×20 $346 $164 $133