Best Self Storage Units in Lindenhurst, NY

In order to pick the top 16 storage units companies in Lindenhurst, we looked at all 152 facilities in the area, including an in-depth review of each company’s amenities, features, and customer reviews.

Our Selection Criteria

Our goal is to connect people with the best local storage facilities. We analyzed every single storage facility in the area and rated them based on 30 different variables to pick the best storage unit facilities in Lindenhurst.

  • shape-1 152
    Facilities Reviewed
  • shape-1 87
    Facilities Curated
  • shape-1 16
    Top Picks
  • 1. Customer Service

    A record of outstanding customer reviews and service.

  • 2. Amenities

    Offers the most important features popular with customers.

  • 3. Location

    Multiple nearby facilities for maximum convenience.

  • 4. Professionalism

    A reputation of honest and reliable business practices.

The 16 Best Storage Facilities in Lindenhurst

Show Map

CitiWide Self Storage

4555 Pearson Street Long Island, NY 11101

CitiWide Self Storage serves residential and commercial customers in Queens, Manhattan, Brooklyn, and the surrounding areas, offering clean and affordable spaces with desirable amenities, including custom unit sizes, units with electricity, large loading docks, freight elevators, pushcarts and pallet jacks, and package acceptance. Over 1,000 units are available, ranging in size from 12 to 2,000 square feet. The company sells a variety of packing and moving supplies and has a dumpster on-site for tenant use.  ...Read More

What customers are saying:

I have been there for both personal and business storage needs for years and am very happy. I highly recommend them.

CubeSmart Self Storage

Multiple Locations

CubeSmart Self Storage offers conventional and climate-controlled units in its securely monitored and well-lit facility. Located near Bethpage Community Park, Oyster Bay Skatepark, and Bethpage State Park, it’s ideal for storing sporting equipment, personal, and business items. Handcarts and dollies are provided for on-site use to make loading and unloading items easier, and elevators are available for upper-level floors. Renters have access to the grounds daily from 6 a.m. to 10 p.m.  ...Read More

What customers are saying:

This storage is nice and clean, the staff is very friendly, and the rates were competitive. I definitely recommend using this facility.

Extra Space Storage

Multiple Locations

Extra Space Storage serves residences and businesses in North Babylon, West Islip, Baywood, and the surrounding communities. The company offers units ranging in size from 25 to 300 square feet and are available with conventional drive-up access and indoor entrance climate-controlled options. Moving carts are provided to make unloading and loading items easier, and upper-level units have elevator access. The facility has wide driveways to accommodate large moving vans, and there's also a loading dock.  ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Showed me the facility and my unit and explained everything in detail. The place was very nice and clean.

Freeport Self Storage

73 East Merrick Road Freeport, NY 11520

Freeport Self Storage offers seven days a week access to stored items, with extended hours for drive-up units. The company has conventional and climate-controlled spaces, with larger units that have 8'x8' doors and high ceilings, ideal for vehicle storage. In addition to security features that include digital video surveillance, burglar alarms, fire alarms, and pick-proof cylinder locks, Freeport Self Storage accepts deliveries and uses mobile apps to make facility entrance and rental payments easier.  ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Very nice place and exceptional customer service. They made me feel comfortable, explained everything, and were very honest with the sizing and price.

Gotham Mini Storage

501 10th Avenue New York, NY 10018

Gotham Mini Storage has solutions for students, residents, and businesses. The company has climate-controlled lockers and units that range in size from 4'x4' to 10'x20' and are accessible around the clock. Packing supplies can be purchased on-site, and the company accepts package deliveries. Commercial clients who need office space can rent workspaces that include a lounge, coffee bar, and Wi-Fi. The property has motion detectors, video surveillance, controlled entry, and on-site staff to keep items safe.  ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Gotham is so wonderful! Everyone was extremely kind and accommodating, the storage unit was wonderful, and the prices are the best in the city.

Life Storage

Multiple Locations

Customers can rent spaces online, by phone, or in-person at Life Storage on East Hoffman Avenue. Located near Irmisch Park, the facility is fully fenced and gated with bright lights, surveillance cameras throughout, and electronic keypad access. The company offers clean and affordable units in conventional and climate-controlled selections, extended access hours, and moving supplies and boxes. Tenants can rent spaces on a short- or long-term basis, and autopay is available. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Phenomenal staff, environment, climate, and rooms. It was a very simple and pleasant process.

Men On The Move

Multiple Locations

Located near Bethpage FCU and Retro Fitness, Men On The Move serves Farmingdale, Bethpage, Hicksville, and the surrounding communities. It offers conventional drive-up and climate-controlled spaces in a wide range of sizes, as well as mailboxes, lockers, and parking for vehicles and RVs. Renters have daily access to their items in the company's secure facility that's monitored with 24-hour surveillance. Men On The Move also offers mobile storage cubes and local and long-distance moving services.  ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Men On The Move storage is the most professional facility we have ever had the privilege to work with.

Omega Self Storage

Multiple Locations

Residential and commercial customers have access to stored items 7 days a week at Omega Self Storage. Units, which range in size from 5'x5' to 10'x20', are secured by 24-hour digital video surveillance and electronic gate access. Renters have drive-up access to their units, and moving carts are provided for on-site use to make loading and unloading items easier. Reservations and rentals can be made by phone, and online bill pay is also available.  ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Very good facility. The location is perfectly easy to get to right off the highway. Always clean and well-lit at night. Surveillance cameras on the premises.

Premier Storage Solutions of West Islip

175 Union Boulevard West Islip, NY 11795

Renters can access their belongings 24/7 at Premier Storage Solutions of West Islip. Conveniently located near the Babylon Northport Expressway, the company offers conventional and climate-controlled storage units, boat and RV parking, and a large selection of boxes and packing materials. The facility's driveways are paved, and outdoor entrance units are drive-up accessible. Access is controlled through an electronic gate, and the facility is well-lit to make unloading and loading belongings easier at any time of day.  ...Read More

What customers are saying:

The staff is friendly, helpful, and easy to work with. I'm at this facility a few times per week, and it's always well maintained and clean.

Prime Storage

Multiple Locations

Prime Storage has standard units, ranging in size from 5'x5' to 10'x25', that are ground-level and drive-up accessible. Some units have individual lights, and there's outdoor parking for cars, trucks, and motorcycles. The property has wide aisles to make it easier to maneuver large moving vans, and the grounds are fully fenced and gated. Boxes and moving supplies can be purchased on-site, and renters can access their units daily from 6 a.m. to 10 p.m. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Great service! [Staff member] is great, good customer service, very nice.

Public Storage

Multiple Locations

Whether they need indoor, outdoor, conventional, or climate-controlled storage, Public Storage has solutions for residential and business customers. Located near Belmont Lake State Park and Southern State Parkway, the facility offers units ranging in size from 5'x5' to 10'x20' and is well-lit with keypad access seven days per week and staff members on-site to assist with rental questions. Public Storage offers short- and long-term lease options and has a variety of moving supplies for purchase. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Helpful staff. Clean location. Prices were fair.

Safeguard Self Storage

Multiple Locations

Units at Safeguard Self Storage have individual door alarms, Bluetooth security and are available in conventional, heated, and air-conditioned selections. The facility gives customers access seven days a week and also has auto and boat storage, digital video monitoring, and a facility-wide intercom system to give customers peace of mind when loading and unloading items. There is a drive-in loading dock, and Safeguard Self Storage accepts deliveries for tenants.  ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Space is clean, efficiently laid out, and the bonus of pulling the vehicle inside to load/unload without concern about the weather is a huge plus.

Simply Self Storage

Multiple Locations

With conventional and climate-controlled units in a wide range of sizes, as well as parking for vehicles and RVs, Simply Self Storage serves Lindenhurst, West Babylon, and the surrounding communities, offering options for every need and budget. The facility has several convenience features, including wide aisles for moving truck access, elevators for upper-level units, and packing supplies available for purchase. Important security features include indoor and outdoor lighting, 24-hour cameras, keypad access, and perimeter fencing. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Very clean establishment. [The manager] is very helpful and thorough. Seems very secure and well lit.

Storage Sense

180 Travis Street Lindenhurst, NY 11757

Storage Sense offers indoor temperature-controlled units, ranging in size from 3'x5' to 20'x40,' that are ideal for storing business and personal items. Lockers, mailboxes, and outdoor parking for vehicles, boats, and RVs are also available. The facility is monitored 24/7 by recording cameras, and staff members are on-site to assist customers with rental questions. Packing supplies and boxes can be purchased in the rental office and tenants have access to their units daily. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

[The manager] was great. Explained everything about the facilities and made the experience pleasant. The facilities are clean and secure. You know your personal items are in a good place.

StorQuest Self Storage

260 Farmingdale Road West Babylon, NY 11704

Customers can access belongings 24/7 at StorQuest Self Storage. Located near Great South Bay and Sunrise Highway, the company offers traditional and climate-controlled spaces ideal for storing fishing gear, sporting equipment, personal goods, and business items. There's also parking for boats, vehicles, and RVs. The facility features a loading stall, ample interior and exterior lighting, electronic gates, and 24-hour digital surveillance. Moving supplies and boxes can be purchased on-site as well. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

I had a great experience. [The team member] took his time explaining the costs and details. He walked me to the storage location, asked me if I had any questions. Very professional.

Sunrise Storage LLC

436 Sunrise Highway West Babylon, NY 11704

Residential and business customers can have peace of mind their belongings are secure at Sunrise Storage LLC. The facility has on-site management, 24-hour digital video monitoring of all hallways, lobbies, and entrances, and fire systems throughout. Renters have around-the-clock access to their units, and bright lights inside and outside the building allow visibility of items at all hours. Units range in size from 5'x5' to 10'x25' and are available in standard and climate-controlled selections.  ...Read More

What customers are saying:

A clean facility with an always pleasant and accommodating staff. Sunrise Storage should always be your first stop when you're looking for a rental unit.

The Cost of Self Storage in Lindenhurst, NY

The average costs of storage units in Lindenhurst are above the state and national averages for the most common storage unit sizes. Storage unit costs will vary depending on the various amenities the facility offers, so shop around to make sure you’re only paying for what you need.

The average cost of storage units in Lindenhurst compared to state and national averages
Size of Storage Unit City Average State Average National Average
5×5 $84 $52 $41
5×10 $92 $86 $59
10×10 $143 $140 $95
10×15 $194 $176 $114
10×20 $247 $164 $133