Filters Sort
Map View
$
$
  • Price (low to high)
  • Price (high to low)
  • Ratings (low to high)
  • Ratings (high to low)
Clear All
Find Cheap Storage in New York
190 Cheap Self Storage Units in Garden City, NY (from $2)

Book a storage unit in Garden City, New York today. Compare available unit sizes, prices, amenities, customer reviews, and other features of 190 facilities in the area.

61 - 90 of 190 storage facilities near Garden City, NY
< 1 2 3 4 ... 7 >
15 - 91 Sq. Ft.
Storage Post - Mott Haven (Bronx)
$9 - $195
Bronx, NY 10454
4.5 stars
16.02 miles away
Self Storage
20 - 75 Sq. Ft.
Storage Post - Melrose (Bronx)
$23 - $183
Bronx, NY 10451
4 stars
16.06 miles away
Self Storage
25 - 80 Sq. Ft.
Storage Post - Morrisania
$21 - $235
Bronx, NY 10456
4 stars
16.08 miles away
Self Storage
15 - 275 Sq. Ft.
Affordable Self Storage - 1680 Atlantic Ave
$39 - $694
Brooklyn, NY 11213
16.12 miles away
Self Storage
25 - 70 Sq. Ft.
Storage Post - East Tremont (Bronx)
$49 - $285
Bronx, NY 10457
4.5 stars
16.17 miles away
Self Storage
25 - 300 Sq. Ft.
Snapbox Self Storage - Mount Vernon - 275 Washington Street
$29 - $380
Mount Vernon, NY 10553
4 stars
16.2 miles away
Self Storage
25 - 100 Sq. Ft.
Public Storage - Brooklyn - 1062 Saint Johns Pl
$89 - $296
Brooklyn, NY 11213
4.5 stars
16.63 miles away
Self Storage
9 - 150 Sq. Ft.
Public Storage - Bronx - 385 Gerard Ave
$18 - $357
Bronx, NY 10451
4.5 stars
16.7 miles away
Self Storage
15 - 150 Sq. Ft.
SecureSpace Self Storage Manhattan
$25 - $907
New York, NY 10128
5 stars
16.71 miles away
Self Storage
25 - 70 Sq. Ft.
GoodFriend Self-Storage - Upper East Side - 124th St
$19 - $219
New York, NY 10035
5 stars
16.71 miles away
Self Storage
25 - 150 Sq. Ft.
Public Storage - Brooklyn - 1534 Utica Ave
$44 - $383
Brooklyn, NY 11234
4.5 stars
16.72 miles away
Self Storage
16 - 5700 Sq. Ft.
Prime Storage - Harlem
$25 - $30000
New York, NY 10037
5 stars
16.97 miles away
Self Storage
9 - 180 Sq. Ft.
Prime Storage - Bronx - University Ave
$34 - $396
Bronx, NY 10452
3.5 stars
17.14 miles away
Self Storage
25 - 100 Sq. Ft.
Storage Post - University Heights (Bronx)
$9 - $233
Bronx, NY 10468
4.5 stars
17.26 miles away
Self Storage
25 - 100 Sq. Ft.
Public Storage - Brooklyn - 72 Emerson Place
$101 - $262
Brooklyn, NY 11205
4.5 stars
17.34 miles away
Self Storage
4 - 81 Sq. Ft.
Storage Post - Brooklyn (Grand Ave)
$9 - $245
Brooklyn, NY 11205
4.5 stars
17.44 miles away
Self Storage
25 - 200 Sq. Ft.
iStore Green- Free PICK-UP SERVICE
$5 - $350
Brooklyn, NY 11205
4.5 stars
17.53 miles away
Self Storage
25 - 150 Sq. Ft.
StorQuest - Deer Park / Grand
$37 - $175
Deer Park, NY 11729
4.5 stars
17.61 miles away
Self Storage
12 - 75 Sq. Ft.
Storage Post - East Village
$24 - $504
New York, NY 10009
5 stars
17.86 miles away
Self Storage
1 - 128 Sq. Ft.
Lockaway Self Storage
$10 - $554
Brooklyn, NY 11205
5 stars
17.88 miles away
Self Storage
12 - 90 Sq. Ft.
Storage Post - Washington Heights
$37 - $281
New York, NY 10040
17.96 miles away
Self Storage
25 - 150 Sq. Ft.
Public Storage - Brooklyn - 2461 Knapp Street
$123 - $434
Brooklyn, NY 11235
4.5 stars
18.14 miles away
Self Storage
15 - 784 Sq. Ft.
Brooklyn
$49.95 - $3130
Brooklyn, NY 11201
18.33 miles away
Self Storage
9 - 100 Sq. Ft.
Storage Post - Upper West Side
$52 - $900
New York, NY 10024
18.35 miles away
Self Storage
25 - 264 Sq. Ft.
Public Storage - Brooklyn - 269 Gold St
$43 - $599
Brooklyn, NY 11201
5 stars
18.39 miles away
Self Storage
25 - 300 Sq. Ft.
Public Storage - Commack - 5052 Jericho Turnpike
$30 - $634
Commack, NY 11725
4.5 stars
18.65 miles away
Self Storage
20 - 150 Sq. Ft.
Public Storage - Northport - 400 Fort Salonga Road
$48 - $248
Northport, NY 11768
5 stars
18.99 miles away
Self Storage
12 - 264 Sq. Ft.
StorQuest - Port Chester / Highland
$19 - $261
Port Chester, NY 10573
5 stars
19.12 miles away
Self Storage
20 - 250 Sq. Ft.
Prime Storage - Bayshore - Pine Aire Drive
$40 - $400
Bay Shore, NY 11706
3 stars
19.35 miles away
Self Storage
16 - 140 Sq. Ft.
Storage Post - Yonkers
$34 - $337
Yonkers, NY 10701
4.5 stars
19.72 miles away
Self Storage
Showing 30 out of 190 units
< 1 2 3 4 ... 7 >

Storage Units AI Wizard

Not sure the right storage unit for your needs? Our AI wizard is here to help.

  1. 1Create a list of items you want to store
  2. 2Select your location from the database
  3. 3Get personalized advice on unit size and amenities
Image related to Storage Units AI Wizard
frame-logo
Storage Units AI Wizard

Not sure the right storage unit for your needs? Our AI wizard is here to help.

What do you need to store? Create a list of items by selecting the quantity and item name.

Please Enter Quantity

Please Enter Item Name

    frame-logo
    Storage Units AI Wizard

    Not sure the right storage unit for your needs? Our AI wizard is here to help.

    We're getting you analysis based on Garden City, NY.

    If you want to use another location click here.

    Please Enter State Name

    • Loading...

    Please Enter City Name

    • Please select a state first
    frame-logo
    Storage Units AI Wizard

    Not sure the right storage unit for your needs? Our AI wizard is here to help.

    Please wait while we calculate your ideal storage unit size.

    Garden City’s proximity to Manhattan and high property values mean storage costs run well above national averages. With limited space and dense suburban living, you’ll want to focus on security features and climate protection to justify the premium pricing.

    Average Storage Unit Prices in Garden City, NY

    Here’s what you can expect to pay for Garden City storage units:

    5’x5′ $75
    10’x10′ $218
    10’x15′ $310
    10’x20′ $415

    What to Look for in a Garden City Storage Unit

    • Temperature Stability: Long Island’s humid summers and cold winters make climate control essential for protecting furniture, electronics, and documents from warping and moisture damage.
    • Enhanced Security: With property values high and theft concerns in Nassau County, prioritize facilities with surveillance cameras, gated access, and individual unit alarms.
    • Commuter-Friendly Access: Given the area’s heavy LIRR traffic and Manhattan commuters, look for 24-hour access and drive-up units to accommodate busy schedules.
    • Space Efficiency: High rental costs mean maximizing every square foot—choose facilities with tall ceilings and efficient layouts to get the most value.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Are there storage facilities near the LIRR station?

    Yes. Several facilities are located within a short drive of Garden City’s train station, making them convenient for commuters who need quick access.

    Do I need insurance for high-value items in storage?

    Yes. Given Garden City’s premium storage costs, consider additional coverage beyond basic homeowner’s insurance for valuable electronics or furniture.

    Can I store business inventory in Garden City?

    Yes. Many local professionals use storage for office supplies, seasonal inventory, or equipment, especially given the area’s limited commercial space.

    Are there discounts for long-term storage?

    Some facilities offer reduced rates for annual leases or multi-month commitments, which can help offset Garden City’s higher-than-average pricing.

    Is elevator access important in Garden City facilities?

    Yes. Many storage buildings are multi-story, so elevator access saves time and effort when moving heavy items to upper floors.

    Get facility hours and directions.